A long debated topic is whether keeping fish in captivity is cruel. Certain people feel that it is wrong to keep fish in captivity and is extremely unfair for a fish to be enclosed in a space. Certain people feel that the methods of obtaining fish to supply the demand are unethical, while others feel that fishes are subjected to torture in terms of mental and physical well-being when kept in captivity.
Some methods of catching fish can be very cruel, and although illegal, they still continue today. These methods include using an explosive in the water. Some fish are killed immediately (coral and other animals are certainly killed), those who are stunned are collected and sold in the aquarium industry.
These methods primarily take place for the purpose of collecting marine (salt water) fish, as they are harder to breed in captivity and the demand exceeds producers ability to keep up. Because of the demand that fish-keepers have created in this hobby, the suppliers have no choice but to capture marine fish from oceans and seas for sale.
Fish are at the mercy of the owner, and do not have the ability to swim to an area where there is more food. Some owners over crowd the tanks or do not provide the right kind of hiding places that some fish enjoy. The fish are unable to reject these living conditions, and are provided with no stimulation, and are forced to live in a monotonous environment. Such conditions include the state of the water, the living space provided and the frequency of food provided for the fish.
However, other people feel that fish-keeping, with adequate knowledge, can be beneficial for the fish. This argument stems from the points on the safety of the fish and the care provided for the fish when in captivity.
Well-kept aquarium fish have a better shot at living longer than their counterparts in the wild. If the breeds of fish living together are chosen properly, the fish do not suffer from aggression, nor do they become part of the food chain. And If you take care not to over-feed or underfeed the fish, supervise children near the aquarium, and pay attention to any changes in how they look and behave, the fish are actually better off than in the wild. To counter the argument that life would be monotonous for a fish, the provision of suitable fish in a community tank or a species tank would mean that fishes can interact with each other. Territorial fishes live in certain territories marked out by themselves in the wild, and this is simulated in the aquarium, where the fish establishes it's area of living and stays there for the rest of the time.
In conclusion, I feel that a reduction of cruelty can be apparent in fish-keeping if owners can provide their fishes with the necessary care and shelter, and choose fishes that are bred by fish farms instead of wild-caught species, while researching on the needs of the fish they intend to look after.
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment